Skip to main content

Film review · 2012

Seven Minutes In The Warsaw Ghetto

***

Reviewed by: Andrew Robertson

Seven Minutes In The Warsaw Ghetto
"Fine model work, excellent production design, an overwhelming sense of menace."

My notes for this excellently executed stop-motion short, set as it is in the deprivation of the Warsaw Ghetto during the Nazi era, feature the word BLEAK. Capital letters, underlined - there's no compromise here, no insinuation of an ultimately happy ending.

The miniatures are crack-faced, aged porcelain, with human eyes staring out of them. Composited, discomfitingly so, real irises, genuine pupils, authentic windows to souls - perched on top of cloth-bound models, with rusted wrist joints like discarded dolls. Fine model work, excellent production design, an overwhelming sense of menace.

Copy pictureEasy done, even before the baleful gaze of a loitering crow, even before a crude drawing of Hitler on a scrap of paper, even before the soldiers arrive. Motivation here is not all stick. There is, in fact, a carrot, but for all those shades of grey, the texture of cloth and clay and historicity, this is a black and white tale.

Johan Oettinger's film is beautifully made, but one is left wondering if these talents would better serve a different story. There are audiences for the bleak. Indeed, Danish export cinema sometimes seems as if it caters exclusively to them, but there is futility elsewhere - human misery is vast enough that one would hope for a different resource to be tapped. Without wanting to trivialise the subject matter, it'd be good to hear something off one of the other albums. For all the inventiveness in presentation and method, and genuinely affecting as they are, it's one ably sustained note but it's one that we've heard before.

Reviewed on: 07 Feb 2013

Source JustWatch

If you like this, try:

Behaviour
Review preview for Behaviour

A triumph, albeit an uneasy one.

Andrew Robertson · 5 out of 5
The Pianist
Review preview for The Pianist

Polanski makes a familiar story of persecution and inhumanity utterly fresh.

Angus Wolfe Murray · 5 out of 5